Hamza alavi in his pioneering work has argued that because of colonial development the institutions of the army and bureaucracy are overdeveloped relative to the ruling classes the land lords, the. Alavi proposed the idea of the overdeveloped state in pakistan, arguing that, even before independence, the propertied classes had already decided the new shape of pakistans government. The state centered approach revived the concept of state and power in the study of comparative politics. State versus nations in pakistan 9 islam on the state. Alavi argued that a the original base of the state apparatus inherited by a postcolonial society lay in the metropole i. Sep 26, 2018 according to one of pakistans leading sociologists, late hamza alavi, at the time of pakistans creation in 1947, the only established institution that the country inherited was the britishtrained army. Hamza alavi the indian debate on the mode of production revolves around the question whether, in the last 15 or 20 years, there has been a decisive movement in indian agriculture from a feudal mode of production to a capitalist mode of production. The focus of his academic work was nationality, gender, fundamentalism and the peasantry. In short, grand theorising in the mould of hamza alavis structural marxism is no. Similar ly, other important markers of the statesponsored national. The theory of the postcolonial state was initiated by hamza alavi42 and was popularised by other third world scholars, such as claude ake, eme ekekwe, john saul and okechukwu ibeanu among others.
From the more abstract issues of state theory, the colonial mode of production and the social structure of south asia under the impact of colonialism, hamza alavi has written on subjects as varied as the role of us aid to. Ias mains political science 2019 expected questions for. Nationhood and the nationalities in pakistan hamza alavi whereas in europe nations were constituted into states, in postcolonial societies the problem is. Hamza alvi 10 april 1921 1 december 2003 was a marxist academic sociologist and activist. Modern plurarist democrartic states pose great threat to fabric of nation state. The literature has considered the activities of international financial institutions as rolling back the state and avoiding the autonomy of the state in several. Internal economy as a cause of military interventions in pakistan.
Alavis argument was made for south asia and not just for pakistan. Apr 18, 2012 the after effects of such an intervention are widely seen in the postcolonial establishment of pakistan where the country suffered due to the institutional imbalances which are described as an overdeveloped state by hamza alavi loomba, 1998, p. But blair made a most dramatic impact by throwing overboard key parts of the labour partys constitutional commitments to statism and social welfare. History will remember him for his theories on the post. Alavi1 post colonial modernt state hamza alavi the. Scholars and critics said on wednesday that the current situation in pakistan could be better understood in the light of theories presented by social scientist hamza alavi. Sep 10, 2015 are you ready for insta 75 days revision plan upsc prelims 2020. Get ready for upsc civil services preliminary exam 2020 with insights insta 75 days revision plan. The argument is premised on the historical specificity of postcolonial societies. Hamza alavis theories and present situation discussed. The state in postcolonial societies socialist register. The only developed states institution, as we see later, is the civilmilitary bureaucracy which, it seems, alavi in his marxian peripheral capitalism paradigm has equated with an overdeveloped state.
Hamza alavi has shown that like other postcolonial regimes the indian state was overdeveloped 10 the british raj had reared a repressive state apparatus which exceeded the needs of an underdeveloped and poor postcolonial state. Bangla desh and the crisis of pakistan hamza alavi the. The object of this article is to raise some fundamental questions about the classical marxist theory of the state in the context of postcolonial societies. Similar ly, other important markers of the state sponsored national. The congress government after 1947 unfortunately chose not to develop an alternative state. We learnt of the struggles of this student group with the politicians of that time, the formation of the inter collegiate body, and the involvement of sarwar, adib rizvi, haroon ahmed, zain alavi and his brother hamza alavi, mazhar saeed, salieem asmi, s. Naveed pirzada 1 the state of pakistan and the world economic system. Another important but less known theory was proposed by hamza alavi, the pakistani marxist political economist. The postcolonial society inherits that overdeveloped apparatus of state and its institutionalized practices through which the operations of the. In an influential essay on pakistan and bangladesh, the state in postcolonial societies pakistan and bangladesh 1972, hamza alavi posited that the postcolonial state was overdeveloped due to its foreign creation. Pdf bureaucracy is the management apparatus of a state administration.
Hamza alvi 10 april 1921 1 december 2003 was a marxist academic sociologist and activist biography. On the contrary, the colonial power established highly developed military and bureaucracy to control these classes, thus the state apparatus was overdeveloped. The articles referred to are alavis the state in post. He argued that while alavi was overly static in his analysis of culture, the foundations of his ideas about the overdeveloped state had held up remarkably well. View notes alavi 1 post colonial modernt state from pol 100 at lahore university of management sciences. Alvi was born in the bohra community in karachi, in the then british india which now constitutes pakistan and migrated in adulthood to the uk.
Dec 18, 2003 as a political activist in britain in the early 1960s, hamza alavi, who has died aged 82, cofounded, with david later lord pitt, a key pressure group of that era, the campaign against racial. An instrument of analysis that may be employed to better grasp pakistans federal dilemmas is that of hamza alavis overdeveloped state. Pdf postcolonial state and bureaucracy in bangladesh. Modern plurarist democrartic states pose great threat continue reading political science 2015. According to alavi, the postcolonial state inherited an overdeveloped state apparatus both bureaucraticmilitary and economic in relation to civil society, and therefore was capable of subordinating indigenous classes.
For this purpose, hamza alavis article, the state in postcolonial societies. The after effects of such an intervention are widely seen in the postcolonial establishment of pakistan where the country suffered due to the institutional imbalances which are described as an overdeveloped state by hamza alavi loomba, 1998, p. Alavi1 post colonial modernt state hamza alavi the state. In the presence of such structural problems, what can be the prospects for stable democratic institutions in pakistan. Hamza alavi collective for social science research. The context of the relative autonomy of the state itself is interpreted as rivalry in statesociety relations for gaining political influence. Like gulliver bound by the lilliputians, our government seems helpless to do anything.
The term overdeveloped refers to the institutional strength of the state bureaucracy, which is composed of strong military and civilian bureaucracy and weak political forces. Alavi observed that the social classes within the centres of capitalism are developed symmetrically, thus allowing their interests to converge and therefore sustaining functioning democratic civil societies. May 15, 20 hamza alavi was a thinker, a political activist and, above all, a teacher. To understand the roots of regionalism in pakistan it is imperative to deconstruct the nature of pakistani state.
Are you ready for insta 75 days revision plan upsc prelims 2020. Pakistan and bangladesh t he object of this article is to raise some fundamental questions about the classical marxist theory of the state in the context of postcolonial societies. A path towards underdevelopment introduction the intention of this essay is to explore how the interplay of the world economic system and the pakistani state makes pakistan a periphery of the world economic system and thereby contributes to its own underdevelopment as a subsidiary of the world economic. Shaheed 20 and siddiqa 2007, 67 believe that alavis major contribution towards postcolonial states and societies was his thesis on the overdevelopment. That photo is not of hamza alavi but is of the author of this article in the paper hamza alavi was a famous social activist, political theorist who studied post colonial states like india, pakistan, bangladesh and charted out their characteristics post independence, if u read his theory you may understand current state of pakistan. State bureaucracy is overdeveloped in postcolonial societies. Hamza alavi was a thinker, a political activist and, above all, a teacher. The span of his academic work is truly astonishing. At the moment of independence weak indigenous bourgeoisies. A path towards underdevelopment introduction the intention of this essay is to explore how the interplay of the world economic system and the pakistani state makes pakistan a periphery of the world economic system and thereby contributes to its own underdevelopment as a subsidiary of the world economic system. As a political activist in britain in the early 1960s, hamza alavi, who has died aged 82, cofounded, with david later lord pitt, a key pressure group of that era, the campaign against racial. Alavi and his seminal theory of the overdeveloped postcolonial state alavi.
The nehru years in indian politics university of edinburgh. It was essentially to explain the overarching dominance of the state visavis civil society in a postcolonial setting and was applicable to all of the erstwhile british india. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Hamza alavi the transformation of the labour party had begun before blair. Pakistan and bangladesh the object of this article is to raise some fundamental questions about the classical marxist theory of the state in the context of postcolonial societies. Hamza alavi 1979 argues that the peripheral state is the product of the historical.
State and economy in postcolonial kenya, 19631978 361 and taxation, the state attempted to maximize the flow of african labour to the settler estates. This has had disastrous consequence for the pakistani state. Daily answer writing challenge 6 archives comment on the following in 200 words. View notes alavi1 post colonial modernt state from pol 100 at lahore university of management sciences. The postcolonial society inherits that overdeveloped apparatus of state and its institutionalized practices through which the operations of the indigenous social classes are regulated and controlled. Hamza defined the pakistan that emerged in 1947 as an overdeveloped state, by virtue of the overwhelming influence of its bureaucraticmilitary.
Hamza alavi was born into a bohra business family in karachi in 1921, completed his early education in the city and received higher education at aligarh muslim university and gokhale institute in. The contents of this report reflect the views of the authors who are responsible for the facts and accuracy of the data presented herein. Hamza alavi, pakistans most noted social scientist, died in karachi on. The state centered approach revived the concept of state. The state centered approach revived the concept of state and. The impact of development on women, racialethnic minorities, and the environment.
State and class in kenya notes on the cohesion of the. Hamza alavi gave the concept of overdeveloped state 5, which is quite similar to the amoral familism. This had the effect of curtailing the development of commodity production in the reserves, although this operated selectively and was to some extent determined by world market conditions. Responding, in part, to akhtar in 2014, zaidi took a more critical stance and argued that alavis concept has. According to one of pakistans leading sociologists, late hamza alavi, at the time of pakistans creation in 1947, the only established institution that the country inherited was the britishtrained army. It was then created the patronclient relation and patronage political economy. In this article leys questions some of the formulations on the post. An underdeveloped country with scarce resources inherited, what alavi called, an overdeveloped army.
Ias mains political science 2019 expected questions for 2019. Responding, in part, to akhtar in 2014, zaidi took a more critical stance and argued that alavis concept has no relevance for contemporary pakistan zaidi, s. The congress government after 1947 unfortunately chose not to. Hamza alavi in his pioneering work has argued that because of colonial development the institutions of the army and bureaucracy are overdeveloped relative to. The idea of postcolonial countries focuses on the premise of overdeveloped countries and relative autonomy.
The overdeveloped alavian legacy chapter 2 new perspectives. It was consequently particularly powerful compared to the leading agrarian and industrial classes, the latter being. Alavis argument about the overdeveloped state was arguably in a different context. Hamza alavi is best known and remembered for his academic work. Internal economy as a cause of military interventions in. The rise of bureaucratic authoritarianism in south korea. The articles referred to are alavi s the state in post. Armys business collective for social science research. Imam hamza yusuf is founder and president of zaytuna college in berkeley, cal.
644 419 395 1165 1481 93 1144 792 74 1296 1002 597 457 208 1508 1079 1031 475 1135 1394 75 108 811 106 376 67 1553 699 665 1448 963 384 1435 891 247 1419 862 1347 1006 827 806 1361